26 research outputs found
Comparison of different nonlinear solvers for 2D time-implicit stellar hydrodynamics
Time-implicit schemes are attractive since they allow numerical time steps
that are much larger than those permitted by the Courant-Friedrich-Lewy
criterion characterizing time-explicit methods. This advantage comes, however,
with a cost: the solution of a system of nonlinear equations is required at
each time step. In this work, the nonlinear system results from the
discretization of the hydrodynamical equations with the Crank-Nicholson scheme.
We compare the cost of different methods, based on Newton-Raphson iterations,
to solve this nonlinear system, and benchmark their performances against
time-explicit schemes. Since our general scientific objective is to model
stellar interiors, we use as test cases two realistic models for the convective
envelope of a red giant and a young Sun. Focusing on 2D simulations, we show
that the best performances are obtained with the quasi-Newton method proposed
by Broyden. Another important concern is the accuracy of implicit calculations.
Based on the study of an idealized problem, namely the advection of a single
vortex by a uniform flow, we show that there are two aspects: i) the nonlinear
solver has to be accurate enough to resolve the truncation error of the
numerical discretization, and ii) the time step has be small enough to resolve
the advection of eddies. We show that with these two conditions fulfilled, our
implicit methods exhibit similar accuracy to time-explicit schemes, which have
lower values for the time step and higher computational costs. Finally, we
discuss in the conclusion the applicability of these methods to fully implicit
3D calculations.Comment: Accepted for publication in A&
Chaos and Turbulent Nucleosynthesis Prior to a Supernova Explosion
Three-dimensional (3D), time dependent numerical simulations, of flow of
matter in stars, now have sufficient resolution to be fully turbulent. The late
stages of the evolution of massive stars, leading up to core collapse to a
neutron star (or black hole), and often to supernova explosion and
nucleosynthesis, are strongly convective because of vigorous neutrino cooling
and nuclear heating. Unlike models based on current stellar evolutionary
practice, these simulations show a chaotic dynamics characteristic of highly
turbulent flow. Theoretical analysis of this flow, both in the
Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) framework and by simple dynamic models,
show an encouraging consistency with the numerical results. It may now be
possible to develop physically realistic and robust procedures for convection
and mixing which (unlike 3D numerical simulation) may be applied throughout the
long life times of stars. In addition, a new picture of the presupernova stages
is emerging which is more dynamic and interesting (i.e., predictive of new and
newly observed phenomena) than our previous one.Comment: 11 pages, 2 figures, Submitted to AIP Advances: Stardust, added
figures and modest rewritin
Toward a consistent use of overshooting parametrizations in 1D stellar evolution codes
Several parametrizations for overshooting in 1D stellar evolution
calculations coexist in the literature. These parametrizations are used
somewhat arbitrarily in stellar evolution codes, based on what works best for a
given problem, or even for historical reasons related to the development of
each code. We bring attention to the fact that these different parametrizations
correspond to different physical regimes of overshooting, depending whether the
effects of radiation are dominant, marginal, or negligible. Our analysis is
based on previously published theoretical results, as well as multidimensional
hydrodynamical simulations of stellar convection where the interaction between
the convective region and a stably-stratified region is observed. Although the
underlying hydrodynamical processes are the same, the outcome of the
overshooting process is profoundly affected by radiative effects. Using a
simple picture of the scales involved in the overshooting process, we show how
three regimes are obtained, depending on the importance of radiative effects.
These three regimes correspond to the different behaviors observed in
hydrodynamical simulations so far, and to the three types of parametrizations
used in 1D codes. We suggest that the existing parametrizations for
overshooting should coexist in 1D stellar evolution codes, and should be
applied consistently at convective boundaries depending on the local physical
conditions.Comment: 5 pages, 2 figures, to appear in A&A as a regular paper. Last
version: language editing + typos in Eq. (6) & (9) correcte
Turbulent convection in stellar interiors. III. Mean-field analysis and stratification effects
We present 3D implicit large eddy simulations (ILES) of the turbulent
convection in the envelope of a 5 Msun red giant star and in the oxygen-burning
shell of a 23 Msun supernova progenitor. The numerical models are analyzed in
the framework of 1D Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations. The
effects of pressure fluctuations are more important in the red giant model,
owing to larger stratification of the convective zone. We show how this impacts
different terms in the mean-field equations. We clarify the driving sources of
kinetic energy, and show that the rate of turbulent dissipation is comparable
to the convective luminosity. Although our flows have low Mach number and are
nearly adiabatic, our analysis is general and can be applied to photospheric
convection as well. The robustness of our analysis of turbulent convection is
supported by the insensitivity of the mean-field balances to linear mesh
resolution. We find robust results for the turbulent convection zone and the
stable layers in the oxygen-burning shell model, and robust results everywhere
in the red giant model, but the mean fields are not well converged in the
narrow boundary regions (which contain steep gradients) in the oxygen-burning
shell model. This last result illustrates the importance of unresolved physics
at the convective boundary, which governs the mixing there.Comment: 26 pages, 20 figures, Accepted for publication in Ap
The First 3D Simulations of Carbon Burning in a Massive Star
We present the first detailed three-dimensional hydrodynamic implicit large
eddy simulations of turbulent convection for carbon burning. The simulations
start with an initial radial profile mapped from a carbon burning shell within
a 15 solar mass stellar evolution model. We considered 4 resolutions from 128^3
to 1024^3 zones. These simulations confirm that convective boundary mixing
(CBM) occurs via turbulent entrainment as in the case of oxygen burning. The
expansion of the boundary into the surrounding stable region and the
entrainment rate are smaller at the bottom boundary because it is stiffer than
the upper boundary. The results of this and similar studies call for improved
CBM prescriptions in 1D stellar evolution models.Comment: 5 pages, 3 figures. Published in IAUS 329 on 28/07/1
Linking 1D Evolutionary to 3D Hydrodynamical Simulations of Massive Stars
Stellar evolution models of massive stars are important for many areas of
astrophysics, for example nucleosynthesis yields, supernova progenitor models
and understanding physics under extreme conditions. Turbulence occurs in stars
primarily due to nuclear burning at different mass coordinates within the star.
The understanding and correct treatment of turbulence and turbulent mixing at
convective boundaries in stellar models has been studied for decades but still
lacks a definitive solution. This paper presents initial results of a study on
convective boundary mixing (CBM) in massive stars. The 'stiffness' of a
convective boundary can be quantified using the bulk Richardson number
(), the ratio of the potential energy for restoration of the
boundary to the kinetic energy of turbulent eddies. A 'stiff' boundary
() will suppress CBM, whereas in the opposite case a
'soft' boundary () will be more susceptible to CBM. One
of the key results obtained so far is that lower convective boundaries (closer
to the centre) of nuclear burning shells are 'stiffer' than the corresponding
upper boundaries, implying limited CBM at lower shell boundaries. This is in
agreement with 3D hydrodynamic simulations carried out by Meakin and Arnett
[The Astrophysical Journal 667:448-475, 2007]. This result also has
implications for new CBM prescriptions in massive stars as well as for nuclear
burning flame front propagation in Super-Asymptotic Giant Branch stars and also
the onset of novae.Comment: Accepted for publication (12/12/15) in the Physica Scripta focus
issue on Turbulent Mixing and Beyon
On the relevance of bubbles and potential flows for stellar convection
Recently Pasetto et al. have proposed a new method to derive a convection
theory appropriate for the implementation in stellar evolution codes. Their
approach is based on the simple physical picture of spherical bubbles moving
within a potential flow in dynamically unstable regions, and a detailed
computation of the bubble dynamics. Based on this approach the authors derive a
new theory of convection which is claimed to be parameter free, non-local and
time-dependent. This is a very strong claim, as such a theory is the holy grail
of stellar physics.
Unfortunately we have identified several distinct problems in the derivation
which ultimately render their theory inapplicable to any physical regime. In
addition we show that the framework of spherical bubbles in potential flows is
unable to capture the essence of stellar convection, even when equations are
derived correctly.Comment: 14 pages, 3 figures. Accepted for publication in Monthly Notices of
the Royal Astronomical Society. (Comments and criticism are welcomed
Linking 1D Stellar Evolution to 3D Hydrodynamical Simulations
In this contribution we present initial results of a study on convective
boundary mixing (CBM) in massive stellar models using the GENEVA stellar
evolution code. Before undertaking costly 3D hydrodynamic simulations, it is
important to study the general properties of convective boundaries, such as
the: composition jump; pressure gradient; and `stiffness'. Models for a 15Mo
star were computed. We found that for convective shells above the core, the
lower (in radius or mass) boundaries are `stiffer' according to the bulk
Richardson number than the relative upper (Schwarzschild) boundaries. Thus, we
expect reduced CBM at the lower boundaries in comparison to the upper. This has
implications on flame front propagation and the onset of novae.Comment: 2 pages, 1 figure. To appear in proceedings of the IAU Symposium 307:
New Windows on Massive Stars: Asteroseismology, Interferometry and
Spectropolarimetr